Skip to main content
Cardboard Journal
A small plain brown shipping box, slightly crushed at one corner, sits on the floor with a white paper claim tag tied to it with string

GuidePSA · CGC · TAG · SGC · BGS · Pricing

If a Grader Loses or Damages Your Card, What Do You Get?

Less than you think, and only if you did three things before the box left your hands. What PSA, CGC, TAG, SGC and Beckett each promise, and when the clock runs out.

By Sean · Published · 7 min readLast verified

Illustration

A grader that loses or breaks your card owes you something. It is almost never what the card was worth to you, and at every grader we checked it is nothing at all if the card was lost on the way in, or if you report a problem too late.

This guide covers five graders whose full terms we read on Nov. 14, 2026: PSA, CGC, TAG, SGC and Beckett. The pattern holds across all five, and the details below are the ones that decide whether you get paid.

The short version

  • On the way to the grader, the card is your risk. None of the five covers inbound shipping by default. Insure the package yourself, or buy the grader's own inbound option where it sells one.
  • At the grader, the payout has a ceiling. It is the card's fair market value as the grader judges it, capped by the value tied to your service level or declared on your form. The lower number wins.
  • Coming back, you have days, not weeks, to report a problem. PSA and SGC give you 5 calendar days after delivery to report damage, and Beckett 5 days. CGC gives you 14.
  • The grader decides the value. All five reserve the right to set fair market value themselves.

On the way in: you carry the risk

PSA's terms say it has no liability for damage in transit to PSA, and that you bear the risk of loss "even if PSA provides a shipping label." It also refuses liability for damage caused by packing that does not follow its shipping guide. PSA does not insure inbound packages, but it sells third-party inbound insurance at checkout when you ship by FedEx.

CGC's terms put the risk on you until CGC has received and inspected the items.

TAG says it is not responsible for damage on the way to its facility unless you bought its Submission Kit, which covers up to $1,000 for the order in transit.

SGC's terms rule out any liability for loss or damage while a card is being shipped to SGC, or back to you. Beckett has no liability for loss or damage it can show happened while the card was out of its custody.

What to do: insure the inbound package for the card's real value, with a carrier or insurer that covers ungraded cards at their market value. Not every insurer does; PSA's own coverage page warns about this. Pack exactly as the grader's shipping guide says.

While the grader has it: the ceiling

Every grader caps what it will pay, and the cap is lower than most people assume.

PSA pays "based on the degree of damage or loss," up to the lower of the card's fair market value or the Maximum Insured Value of your service level. PSA sets the fair market value "by any means as we may determine." For a damaged card it can either return the card and pay the drop in value, or keep the card and pay the maximum. To be paid, you must sign PSA's release of claims, and PSA can deduct anything you owe it from the payout. Coverage starts when PSA confirms the card has arrived and runs until the card reaches its next destination.

CGC pays based on its "good faith determination" of fair market value, or the drop in value for damage, and never more than the maximum for your service tier. Its Declared Value Policy adds a second limit: compensation will never exceed the value you wrote on the form. CGC also excludes damage it judges was caused by the card's own condition, such as a brittle or fragile item. A separate clause in the same terms caps CGC's total liability at the fees you paid. The terms do not say how that cap and the tier cap fit together, so on a high-value card, ask CGC in writing before you send it.

SGC pays "based on the degree of damage or loss," up to the lower of the value you declared and the card's fair market value as SGC determines it. The declared value only sets the most you can be paid; SGC's own valuation can be lower. To be paid, you must send whatever documents SGC or its insurer asks for and sign SGC's release of claims. SGC's terms also cap its total liability at the greater of the fees you paid or what its insurance pays out, less the deductible.

Beckett pays the lower of the card's fair market value, set by its own procedures, and any insurance bought through the shipping carrier when you submitted. Its terms add that Beckett's total liability never exceeds the value you declared.

TAG pays the fair market value of the card in its TAG-graded condition, and generally not more than the insured amount. It can only pay on orders insured through its own insurance options: tier coverage once the card arrives, and Premium Protection at $2,500, $5,000 or $10,000 per order on top.

Expect to be paid for the card as the grader received it, not for what it might have become. PSA values a lost card at the time of loss, CGC values it in the condition it arrived in, and Beckett values an ungraded card at its "raw un-graded value at the time of submission," so a card that would have graded a 10 is paid as a raw card. TAG is the exception: it values the card in its TAG-graded condition. PSA, CGC, SGC and Beckett also exclude consequential damages, the money you lost because the card was gone; TAG's help pages do not address them.

Declared value: why the number on the form matters

At PSA, CGC, SGC and Beckett, the value tied to your submission is the ceiling, and setting it low to save on fees lowers the most you can ever be paid. Setting it high does not help either: the payout is still the lower of that number and the grader's own fair market value.

If the grader decides your card is worth more than your tier allows, PSA and CGC can move it to a more expensive tier and charge you the difference, and SGC can raise the fee. PSA says the grade is not affected.

What to do: declare an honest market value. For a raw card, CGC asks for the value of an ungraded copy; for a slab, the value of the same grade.

On the way back: the clock starts at delivery

Report problems fast. These windows are short, and a late report can end the claim.

Damage found on delivery Package never arrived
PSA In writing, within 5 calendar days of receipt Within 17 days of the estimated delivery date, or 30 days from shipping if no estimate was given
CGC Within 14 days of receipt Within 14 days after the estimated delivery date, and no later than 30 days after shipping
SGC In writing, within 5 calendar days of receipt Within 17 calendar days of the estimated delivery date, or 30 days from shipping if no estimate was given
Beckett Within 5 days of receipt No deadline published
TAG No deadline published; email support with the order and cert numbers and photos No deadline published; return shipping with signature confirmation is insured on every order placed on taggrading.com since April 2, 2026

CGC also asks you to inspect a package before signing for it, tell the courier about visible damage right away, keep the box and photograph everything. That is good practice at any grader.

Proving the card was fine when you sent it

This is where most claims fail. TAG says it is generally unable to accept raw "pre-grading" photos as evidence in a dispute, and recommends a thorough video of each card before shipping. Its digital report images show the condition of the card when it arrived.

What to do:

  1. Video each card front and back, in good light, before it goes in the sleeve. Keep the file.
  2. Note the card's market value from sold listings, with the date.
  3. Keep the packing slip, the label and the tracking number.
  4. When the order comes back, open it on video, and check every card against the grader's images and labels the same day.

Before you send anything valuable

  • Read your grader's terms on the day you submit. All five change theirs; the dates we read are listed under Sources.
  • If you submit through a store or a group submitter, their terms apply first, and they can be stricter. A store's insured cap can be lower than the grader's.
  • If a card is worth more than your service level's cap, pay for the higher level. The extra fee is the insurance.

Sources

  1. PSA Submission Services Terms and Conditions, last updated April 22, 2026psacard.com/termsandconditions
  2. PSA Coveragepsacard.com/info/coverage
  3. CGC Cards Services Terms and Conditions, revised April 14, 2026cgccards.com/legal/terms-and-conditions
  4. CGC Cards Declared Value Policycgccards.com/submit/declared-value-policy
  5. TAG Help Center: What if my card is damaged while at TAG? (June 24, 2026)help.taggrading.com/en/articles/10659980-what-if-my-card-is-damaged-while-at-tag
  6. TAG Help Center: What insurance options does TAG offer? (April 3, 2026)help.taggrading.com/en/articles/6747634-what-insurance-options-does-tag-offer
  7. SGC Grading Terms & Conditions, last updated Oct. 30, 2025gosgc.com/terms
  8. Beckett Terms of Service, effective Aug. 7, 2025 (Grading and Authentication Services)beckett.com/tos

More guides

All guides

Corrections and feedback

This site is only as good as the data behind it. If something looks wrong, out of date or missing, or you have a thought about it, tell us and we'll take a look.

Contact Us