Ranked by score
All 40 graders| # | Grader | Score | Resale standing | From | Turnaround |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | PSAThe slab resale buyers pay the most for, owned by Collectors Holdings, which also owns SGC and Beckett. | 86Tier S | Premium | $39.99Value, cards up to $500 | 90–100 days |
| 2 | SGCThe vintage collector's slab of choice, no longer the fast option it was known for, and owned by Collectors Holdings, which also owns PSA. | 69Tier A | Accepted | $50Standard, cards up to $1,500 | 40+ days |
| 3 | CGCThe strongest alternative to PSA for Pokémon and Magic, owned by Blackstone rather than Collectors Holdings; its slabs sell a little under PSA's. | 67Tier A | Accepted | $17Bulk, 25-card minimum, cards up to $500 | 90 days (Economy) |
| 4 | BGSThe subgrade specialist and still the pick for high-end modern chrome, owned by Collectors Holdings alongside PSA and SGC. | 60Tier B | Accepted | $79.95Express | 15 days |
| 5 | TAGItemizes every point deduction from machine imaging; resale buyers still pay more for PSA's label than for TAG's evidence. | 57Tier B | Emerging | $29.95Value, 10-card minimum, cards up to $250 | About 45 business days (Standard) |
| 6 | MNT GradingA Canadian hockey specialist with a steady record in that niche and little resale presence outside it. | 44Tier C | Regional | $10.52 (CA$15)Rush, 20+ cards | Varies |
| 7 | KSA CertificationOne of the oldest independent graders, running since 1996 and respected in Canadian hockey, with thin resale demand outside that niche. | 43Tier C | Regional | $10.52 (CA$15)100+ cards | 40–75 days |
| 8 | DSGIssues a 32-subgrade report at one flat price, more documentation than almost any other grader; resale buyers have not priced that in yet. | 41Tier C | Raw value | $12Standard, over 100 cards | 10 days |
| 9 | Ace GradingA UK grader and the sensible choice for Pokémon in the UK or EU; US buyers pay no premium for its slabs. | 38Tier D | Regional | $23.81 (£18)Basic | 30 business days |
| 10 | Rare EditionSells a striking display case, and its price runs ahead of any resale benefit the grade brings. | 38Tier D | Raw value | $39Gold | 20 days |
| 11 | AGSGrades by machine with eight subgrades online, and most collectors use it to pre-screen cards rather than to sell in its slab. | 36Tier D | Raw value | $15Standard Bulk (TCG), 30-card minimum, cards up to $100 | 20 days |
| 13 | DCI GradingA Dallas boutique grader with a regional following; outside its own customers, a DCI slab carries no premium. | 35Tier D | Raw value | $25Slab | 14 business days (RCR); 30 for a slab |
| 14 | CGAAn Australian grader for the Asia-Pacific market; three different things share the CGA initials, so check which one a listing means. | 34Tier D | Raw value | $7.80 (A$11.50)Bulk+, 300-card minimum | Varies by service |
| 15 | RCGA young grader with modern slabs and four subgrades on the label, and little resale recognition, so grade there for your own collection. | 33Tier D | Raw value | $20Revolution, 20+ cards | 25–30 days |
| 16 | ISAOne of the early alternative graders, operating since 2010, with little resale recognition to show for it. | 32Tier D | Raw value | $15Grading, 10-card minimum | 14 days |
| 17 | Edge GradingA machine-led grader founded in 2024, better known for the survey it publishes than for its slabs. | 31Tier D | Raw value | $20Grading, 10+ cards | 4–8 days |
| 18 | Mana GradingPublishes its reasoning for each grade, which almost no other grader does; its slabs sell at raw value. | 31Tier D | Raw value | $11.70Bulk Order, 100-card minimum | 20–25 days |
| 19 | FCGA boutique grader with a defined view on eye appeal; its slabs carry little resale weight, so grade there for your own collection. | 30Tier D | Raw value | $15Flat rate | 10 days |
| 20 | MBAMBA does two jobs: it grades raw cards in its own holder, and it stickers other graders' slabs with a second opinion. | 30Tier D | Raw value | $15Raw grading, Standard | 30 business days |
| 21 | TGACompetes on price and speed rather than reputation, a poor trade for any card you plan to sell. | 30Tier D | Raw value | $16Value, 15-card minimum | 5 days |
| 22 | Golden GradingGrades for $5 a card in a slab that reads as Beckett at a glance, and its serial lookup could not find our card. | 29Tier D | Raw value | $5Economy | 10 days (Express) |
| 23 | Aura GradingA low-cost grader that is strict on its lowest subgrade and rounds every half-grade up; an unrelated UK grader shares its name. | 29Tier D | Raw value | $9Bulk, 50-card minimum | 2–3 weeks |
| 24 | Degree GradingExplains each grade in more detail than almost any other grader, and resale buyers show little interest in its slabs. | 25Tier D | Raw value | $15Bulk, 10-card minimum | About 47 business days |
| 26 | TCGA grader called Trading Card Grading that is not TCGplayer, and the shared name is the most confusing thing about it. | 23Tier D | Raw value | $10.86 (A$16)Routine per card | 50–60 business days |
| 27 | ARK GradingAlmost nothing about ARK can be verified in public, and that absence is our finding. | 22Tier D | Raw value | $15.61 (A$23)Economy | 65 days (Economy) |
| 28 | GASAlmost nothing independent is known about GAS, and for a grader you trust with your card's value, that is the answer. | 22Tier D | Raw value | $8Single rate, 100-card minimum | 14 days |
Not taking submissions now: CSG, Granite State Grading.
The number beside each grader is its place in the full ranking. Built from each grader's scorecard, so this list changes when a scorecard does. "From" is the cheapest graded slab open to anyone, in US dollars at the Nov. 13, 2026 exchange rate where a grader prices in another currency.
