Skip to main content
Cardboard Journal

ScorecardsPokémon and TCG

Graders for Pokémon and other card games

Every grader we track that takes trading card games: Pokémon, Magic, One Piece, Lorcana and the rest. Ranked by what the resale market pays for the slab.

28 of the 40 graders we track, 27 taking submissions.

Ranked by score

All 40 graders
Graders for Pokémon and other card games, with score, resale standing, cheapest price and typical turnaround
#GraderScoreResale standingFromTurnaround
1PSAThe slab resale buyers pay the most for, owned by Collectors Holdings, which also owns SGC and Beckett.86Tier SPremium$39.99Value, cards up to $50090–100 days
2SGCThe vintage collector's slab of choice, no longer the fast option it was known for, and owned by Collectors Holdings, which also owns PSA.69Tier AAccepted$50Standard, cards up to $1,50040+ days
3CGCThe strongest alternative to PSA for Pokémon and Magic, owned by Blackstone rather than Collectors Holdings; its slabs sell a little under PSA's.67Tier AAccepted$17Bulk, 25-card minimum, cards up to $50090 days (Economy)
4BGSThe subgrade specialist and still the pick for high-end modern chrome, owned by Collectors Holdings alongside PSA and SGC.60Tier BAccepted$79.95Express15 days
5TAGItemizes every point deduction from machine imaging; resale buyers still pay more for PSA's label than for TAG's evidence.57Tier BEmerging$29.95Value, 10-card minimum, cards up to $250About 45 business days (Standard)
6MNT GradingA Canadian hockey specialist with a steady record in that niche and little resale presence outside it.44Tier CRegional$10.52 (CA$15)Rush, 20+ cardsVaries
7KSA CertificationOne of the oldest independent graders, running since 1996 and respected in Canadian hockey, with thin resale demand outside that niche.43Tier CRegional$10.52 (CA$15)100+ cards40–75 days
8DSGIssues a 32-subgrade report at one flat price, more documentation than almost any other grader; resale buyers have not priced that in yet.41Tier CRaw value$12Standard, over 100 cards10 days
9Ace GradingA UK grader and the sensible choice for Pokémon in the UK or EU; US buyers pay no premium for its slabs.38Tier DRegional$23.81 (£18)Basic30 business days
10Rare EditionSells a striking display case, and its price runs ahead of any resale benefit the grade brings.38Tier DRaw value$39Gold20 days
11AGSGrades by machine with eight subgrades online, and most collectors use it to pre-screen cards rather than to sell in its slab.36Tier DRaw value$15Standard Bulk (TCG), 30-card minimum, cards up to $10020 days
12PCA GradeThe European default for Pokémon grading, with little presence in the American resale market.36Tier DRegional$12.05 (€10.90)Classic, 10+ cards, cards up to $275.20 (€249)1 month (Fast)
14CGAAn Australian grader for the Asia-Pacific market; three different things share the CGA initials, so check which one a listing means.34Tier DRaw value$7.80 (A$11.50)Bulk+, 300-card minimumVaries by service
15RCGA young grader with modern slabs and four subgrades on the label, and little resale recognition, so grade there for your own collection.33Tier DRaw value$20Revolution, 20+ cards25–30 days
16ISAOne of the early alternative graders, operating since 2010, with little resale recognition to show for it.32Tier DRaw value$15Grading, 10-card minimum14 days
17Edge GradingA machine-led grader founded in 2024, better known for the survey it publishes than for its slabs.31Tier DRaw value$20Grading, 10+ cards4–8 days
18Mana GradingPublishes its reasoning for each grade, which almost no other grader does; its slabs sell at raw value.31Tier DRaw value$11.70Bulk Order, 100-card minimum20–25 days
20MBAMBA does two jobs: it grades raw cards in its own holder, and it stickers other graders' slabs with a second opinion.30Tier DRaw value$15Raw grading, Standard30 business days
21TGACompetes on price and speed rather than reputation, a poor trade for any card you plan to sell.30Tier DRaw value$16Value, 15-card minimum5 days
22Golden GradingGrades for $5 a card in a slab that reads as Beckett at a glance, and its serial lookup could not find our card.29Tier DRaw value$5Economy10 days (Express)
24Degree GradingExplains each grade in more detail than almost any other grader, and resale buyers show little interest in its slabs.25Tier DRaw value$15Bulk, 10-card minimumAbout 47 business days
25Arena ClubBundles grading with a vault and marketplace, which helps if you sell inside Arena Club; outside it, the slab carries little weight.24Tier DRaw value$15Grade and vault~30 business days (estimated, per support)
27ARK GradingAlmost nothing about ARK can be verified in public, and that absence is our finding.22Tier DRaw value$15.61 (A$23)Economy65 days (Economy)
28GASAlmost nothing independent is known about GAS, and for a grader you trust with your card's value, that is the answer.22Tier DRaw value$8Single rate, 100-card minimum14 days
30GMA Grading & AuthenticationThe cheapest way to put a card in a holder, fine for bulk and the wrong choice for any card you want to sell.20Tier DRaw value$9Economy, 100+ cards25 days
33GSGGold Standard Grading slabs show up in eBay searches across all three card categories, and little else about it is established.12Tier DRaw value$20.88 (€18.89)No subgrades, 60+ cards6 weeks
34C3 GradingA new flat-rate grader with a horizontal slab and four subgrades online, and no independent record yet to judge it on.8Tier DRaw value$9Flat rate2–3 weeks

Not taking submissions now: HGA.

The number beside each grader is its place in the full ranking. Built from each grader's scorecard, so this list changes when a scorecard does. "From" is the cheapest graded slab open to anyone, in US dollars at the Nov. 13, 2026 exchange rate where a grader prices in another currency.

Should You Switch Graders? How to Decide for One Card

Corrections and feedback

This site is only as good as the data behind it. If something looks wrong, out of date or missing, or you have a thought about it, tell us and we'll take a look.

Contact Us