Skip to main content
Cardboard Journal

← The Wire

The Wire · Opinion

Argument, not reporting.

The rest of the wire reports what happened. These pieces argue what it means: signed, with the author's interests declared at the top, and built on the reporting they link back to.

7 pieces, newest first

Latest argumentOpinion · BGS · Market acceptance

Beckett’s Recovery, Phase 2: Still Waiting on Answers

Back: accounts, submissions, pop reports, cert lookup. Not back: price guide, Marketplace.

On 2 October, Beckett said it had detected “suspicious technical activity,” taken its platforms offline and brought in outside security experts for a forensic investigation. By then, beckett.com had been a holding page since 9 September, a gap of roughly three weeks between the outage and the first explanation.

Opinion. By Cardboard Journal, 17 OctRead the argument

Earlier pieces

OpinionPSA, SGC, CGCPricingBy Cardboard Journal

A grader should grade the card, not charge you for what it's worth

At PSA, the same five-day grade costs $999 or $13,191. Nothing about the service changes. Only the price of the card does.

OpinionPSAOwnershipBy Cardboard Journal

PSA swears it has no stake in your sale. It's paid a percentage of the price.

PSA grades your card, then sells it for a cut of the price, so the higher it goes, the more PSA makes. Its own site still promises it has nothing riding on the sale.

OpinionPSA, SGC, CGC, BGSGrading methodBy Cardboard Journal

Nobody can prove PSA is better than anyone

The biggest graders sell certainty, and none has been measured against a common, independent benchmark. Until someone grades the graders, a PSA 10 is a reputation, not a verified standard.

OpinionBGSMarket acceptanceBy Cardboard Journal

It took Beckett 23 days to say "suspicious". The rest of its statement is still vague.

Beckett has admitted a security scare. Its careful wording still leaves customers guessing.

OpinionBGSCapacityBy Cardboard Journal

Beckett's rebuild looks like recovery, not a plan

Until Beckett gives a date and says plainly whether customer data was involved, do not send it cards.

OpinionBGS, Golden GradingMarket acceptanceBy Cardboard Journal

Golden's slab looks like Beckett's. Only one of them travels.

Buy the card, not the holder — and price a Golden slab as a nice case.

See An Error? Have Feedback?

This site is only as good as the data behind it. If something looks wrong, out of date, or missing — or you just have a thought about it — tell us and we'll take a look.

Contact Us