Start here
Guides
Plain-language explainers on the decisions that cost money. Read these before you spend anything on grading — first-hand submission walkthroughs follow below.
Published
6 of 6 writtenThe Number Everyone Reads in a Pop Report Is the Wrong One
What the columns mean, why the gem rate matters more than the raw count, and the ways a pop figure misleads.
Read guide →Graders Take the Lowest Score. Find It Before They Do.
Centering, corners, edges, surface — what graders look for before you submit.
Read guide →Most Cards Should Not Be Graded. Is Yours the Exception?
Where to look up what a card is worth, how to check the grade you are likely to get, and the arithmetic that turns both into a yes or a no.
Read guide →If the Cert Number Does Not Resolve, It Is Not a Slab
Real third-party grading vs. fake magnetic cases — how to tell the difference.
Read guide →The Cheapest Grade on the Market Is the One You Cannot Sell
Red flags that separate real third-party grading from operations that won't hold value at resale.
Read guide →Everyone Has a 10 of This Card. Should You Switch Graders?
The top grade is not scarce at your usual grader. Whether a different one actually helps — and the narrow cases where it does.
Read guide →Submission walkthroughs
Every scorecard here tells you what a grader claims. These will tell you what actually happened — one real submission at a time, from the order form to the box coming back, with the receipts.
What each walkthrough will report
Coming soon — nothing published yet
01
The process
What the submission form actually asks for, how the cards have to be packed, and the steps that are vague enough to cost you a mistake.
02
What it really cost
Grading fees, declared value, postage both ways, insurance, and any upcharge that only shows up at checkout. The total landed cost, not the headline rate.
03
How long it really took
Days from the box leaving to the slabs arriving, set against the turnaround the grader advertised on the day the order went in.
04
What came back
Slab and label quality, how the grades compare to the same cards elsewhere, and any damage, mis-labelling or service problem — reported whether or not it flatters the grader.
These publish as cards are actually submitted, so the list grows at the speed of real orders rather than on a content schedule. Nothing here will be second-hand.