Skip to main content
Cardboard Journal

← The Wire

PGI deliberately grades the cards the majors don't want

The only sensible fit is sub-$100 post-1980 cards and the foreign issues the majors ignore.

Cardboard JournalOur analysis

Defining yourself by what you will not grade is rarer than it sounds, and PGI has done it deliberately: raw value under $100, produced after 1980, $12.50 a card with a 25-card minimum.

That constraint is what makes the price sustainable. A grader that accepts anything has to carry the insurance, handling and dispute risk of high-value cards, and those costs land on every submission. Refusing that segment is how $12.50 stays $12.50.

The coverage of magazine cards and foreign issues is the part that has no real substitute. The majors underserve those categories because the volume is not there, which means for those specific cards PGI is not the cheap option — it is often the only one. Fit the grader to the card and this works. Ignore the band it defined and it does not.

Back to The Wire

See An Error? Have Feedback?

This site is only as good as the data behind it. If something looks wrong, out of date, or missing — or you just have a thought about it — tell us and we'll take a look.

Contact Us